G o C i n c i n n a t i     F r e e T i m e
h o m e   ·   m o v i e s   ·   d i n i n g   ·   c a l e n d a r s
Fall Arts Guide
A R T   ·   C L A S S I C A L    M U S I C   ·   P O P U L A R    M U S I C
D A N C E   ·   F I L M   ·   T H E A T E R   ·   E V E N T    L O C A T I O N S
C L O S E - U P

FILM CRITIC CLOSE-UP: MARGARET A. McGURK

MEET THE CRITICS
Demaline - Theater
Findsen - Art
Gelfand - Classical
McGurk - Film
Nager - Music
Norris - Dance

STORIES
Art
Classical
Dance
Film
Music
Theater
DATES
Art
Classical
Dance
Film
Music
Theater
Biography: Born and raised in Chicago, I earned my journalistic stripes covering politics and education in my hometown. I did a stint in New Jersey, where I became a kind of newsroom utility infielder -- running the editorial page and managing election coverage, among other assignments. I came to Cincinnati in 1990 as an assistant metro editor. Beginning in college (University of Illinois at Springfield), I had studied and written about film purely as a personal passion. It never crossed my mind that film could become a full-time occupation until 1995, when what features editor Sara Pearce called ''a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity'' presented itself.

Hardly a day goes by when someone doesn't say to me, ''You have the best job in the world.'' To which I can only answer, ''Yes, I most certainly do.''

Philosophy: Movies are an inextricable part of my life, and yours too, whether you go to the theater or not. They influence how we talk, how we dress, what jokes we tell. They mirror the world in fact, and in our imaginations. They make our most elusive selves solid and specific.

Even the frothiest entertainments entice us to participate in emotional experiences as if they were real. Filmmakers who don't understand that -- who don't know what they are saying or have no good reason to ask for our attention -- almost inevitably make bad movies.

That's why I insist that even mindless diversions come across with the goods. Just because a movie is fluff is no reason for it to insult the paying customers with ill-constructed plots, clumsy dialogue and cardboard characters. Clarity of purpose solves a lot of those problems; without it, all the talent and money in the world won't yield a good film (see Sphere).

do not judge movies on a curve. Even though for the convenience of our readers we assign star values to each movie, there is no fair way to make a direct comparison between, say, Saving Private Ryan and There's Something About Mary. I strive to measure each film on how well it achieves what it sets out to do.

Technical standards in the movie business are so high, and filmmakers at all levels so sophisticated, that mechanical shortcomings -- sound, lighting, costumes -- are rarely a major issue. Most of the time, when movies fail, they fail on the page. A good story -- intelligent, engaging, original -- and a well-written script are still the essential ingredients, and the achievements I rate highest.

Pet peeves: Children's movies that show someone getting kicked in the crotch -- which lately are almost all children's movies. People who talk during the show.

What I'd like to see this year: Theatrical engagements for the growing number of low-budget, independent films shot in Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky.

A R T   ·   C L A S S I C A L    M U S I C   ·   P O P U L A R    M U S I C
D A N C E   ·   F I L M   ·   T H E A T E R   ·   E V E N T    L O C A T I O N S
Fall Arts Guide
h o m e   ·   m o v i e s   ·   d i n i n g   ·   c a l e n d a r s
G o C i n c i n n a t i     F r e e T i m e